Home / Compendium / Samuel Bateman / The Samuelites

Samuel Bateman / The Samuelites

An FLDS splinter group led by Samuel Bateman, who declared himself Warren Jeffs's prophetic successor around 2019. Bateman pleaded guilty in 2024 to a child sex trafficking and kidnapping conspiracy involving girls as young as nine, and was sentenced to 50 years in federal prison.

Samuel Rappylee Bateman was a member of the FLDS community in the Short Creek area — Colorado City, Arizona, and Hildale, Utah — the same community long led by Warren Jeffs. After Jeffs was sentenced to life in prison in 2011, leadership within the community fractured.

Around 2019, Bateman began telling followers that Jeffs had died and that he was the group’s new prophet. He drew an estimated 50 followers, informally known as “Samuelites,” and over the following three years assembled more than 20 so-called “spiritual wives,” at least 10 of whom were minors — the youngest reported to be nine years old.

Bateman is currently incarcerated; the group has no known active leadership structure at this time.

Timeline of events

2011
Jeffs sentenced. FLDS leader Warren Jeffs receives a life sentence, destabilizing Short Creek leadership.
~2019
Bateman claims prophethood. He tells followers Jeffs has died and declares himself the new prophet.
2019–2022
Abuse documented. Bateman assembles over 20 "spiritual wives," including at least 10 minors.
Aug 2022
Arrest. Bateman is arrested in Flagstaff, AZ, after girls ages 11–14 are found in a poorly ventilated trailer.
Apr 1, 2024
Guilty plea. Bateman pleads guilty to conspiracy to transport a minor for sexual activity and conspiracy to commit kidnapping.
Dec 9, 2024
Sentencing. Bateman is sentenced to 50 years in federal prison with lifetime supervised release.
Apr 8, 2026
Documentary release. Netflix releases "Trust Me: The False Prophet," built on undercover footage that helped build the case

Sources

  1. [1] Wikipedia — "Samuel Bateman"
  2. [2] CBS News — "Leader of Arizona polygamous sect sentenced to 50 years"
  3. [3] The Salt Lake Tribune — "Polygamous prophet: How FLDS-offshoot leader Samuel Bateman ended up behind bars"
  4. [4] Wikipedia — "Trust Me: The False Prophet"